Door County's historic Hillside Inn of Ephraim overlooks Eagle Harbor and Peninsula State Park

7/5/2008
Hillside Inn, Hotel, Cottage, Ephraim, Door County
Reservations About Us Contact Us 1-866-673-8456
9980 Water Street Ephraim, WI 54211    

Webbs bring back
Hillside Hotel

reprinted from The Door County Advocate
Friday, August 16, 2002

By Jessica La Plant'e
Advocate Correspondent

 


Devising a slogan to draw customers to your doorstep is a challenge for any entrepreneur. But when the new place of business happens to be a famous Door County landmark,, perhaps the only announcement needed to attract customers and community members is simple; "We're now open!”

Such is the case for the old Hillside Hotel of Ephraim. Once again, the landmark resort will become a tourist destination, reopening as bed-and-breakfast establishment operated by James and Clare Webb.

Although August 1 marked the first day of' business for the Hillside Inn, the business venture already has received a great deal of attention from the Ephraim community.

Village President Paul Burton "has come over a couple of times and told us how happy the village is that (the hotel) is still standing:' Clare said. "We’ve met so many supportive people who have been excited about what we're doing."

Stacked nearly three stories high on a bluff overlooking Eagle Harbor, the Hillside Hotel has stood as a prominent part of the Ephraim landscape since 1890. Although the frame of the vintage hotel his endured through decades, the building itself hasn't been quite so time-resistant.

After purchasing the Hillside property last August, the Webbs discovered they had taken on a massive renovation project. To revive the faded beauty the couple hired Sturgeon Bay architect Henry Isaksen and the PortSide Properties construction firm.

The resulting renovation - a spacious bed-and-break-fast with five suits, two guest cottages and newly landscaped yard - did not go unnoticed by Ephraim villagers.

Already, residents have, “come up to us and thanked us for what we’ve done:' Clare said. "One woman told me that she never turned to look at (the hotel) because it was so sad and dilapidated, and now she looks at it and smiles."

Yet community members aren't the only ones pleased to know that a century-old tradition will endure. Former patrons of the hotel are just as delighted to see the legendary lodge reopen.

"I sent quite a few, mailers to people who had stayed here years ago, and about 200 were returned Clare said, adding that she has received a number of phone inquires from former guests as well.

Of course, the same charming features that captured the hearts of hotel patrons in the past had cast a spell upon the Webbs, inspiring them to relocate from Los Angeles to Ephraim and in their hands at innkeeping.

Last August, while vacationing at their cottage in Sister Bay. the Webbs noticed a "for sale" sign posted in the front yard of the Ephraim resort. Immediately, they inquired about the status of the property. only to hear the heartbreaking rumor that an offer to purchase had already been made.

Refusing to cast aside hope, Clare called the broker and, to her amazement, learned that the prospective buyer was backing out of the real estate deal. The Webbs jumped at the opportunity to make the Ephraim landmark their full-time home.

Even prior to that pivotal event, fate intervened in another way that made an otherwise unaffordable piece of real estate more accessible to the Webbs. The original Hillside sales package included a large strip of beachfront property, the cost of which would have priced the hotel beyond the Webb's reach.

But then the bavshore lot was acquired by Ephraim village officials to develop a public park. With the beachfront in village hands. the asking price for the hotel dropped dramatically.

Following the real estate transaction and months of restoration work, the Webbs were at last ready to pick up where the previous owners had left off two years ago, continuing a century-old tradition of Ephraim hospitality.
To capture the magic of Door County in the summertime, Clare appointed each room in simple yet elegant colors, making full use of light blues and green to compliment thee white walls and sun glossed hardwood floors.

"We wanted the rooms to be as nice as any luxury hotel one would stay at in California or New York (yet have) a comfortable Door County look,” Clare said.

The new proprietors hope to restore the Ephraim Landmark to the popularity it enjoyed a century ago, when the Norwegian family of Morton and Maria Olson operated the hotel. The Olson's made the guesthouse famous for sumptuous cuisine and even more savory waterfront views.

Despite the rustic atmosphere sported by the Hillside Hotel decades ago, the resort featured just 12 upper-level sleeping quarters, each no larger than a child’s bedroom. The saving feature was the luxurious grounds.

When guests were nor relishing Mrs. Olson's legendary cooking, they were savoring the panoramic view of Eagle Harbor. On many evenings, visitors could drink with their eyes from the breathtaking scenery, taking in the sunset much like a connoisseur would sip a glass of dessert wine.

In fact, it was that very spectacle that renewed the Webbs’ sense of enthusiasm every time the renovation project overwhelmed them.

“We would come in the evening before the sun would go down… the windows upstairs were very small then so you’d have to stoop down … and we’d (look out and) say, ‘Oh, that’s a gorgeous sunset!’” Jim said.

“That was part of our encouragement for wanting to be here,” Clare added.

More than just acquiring a resort building, the Webbs also inherited a never-ending project when the purchased the hotel. For starters, the upstairs rooms begged to be converted into more spacious quarters, the dark-colored walls longed for a white-wash; and at least one wing of the building required a complete reconstruction.

And the hotel was not the only structure on the property demanding attention. A pair of guest cottages nestled alongside the main building also needed refurbishing.

Despite the scope of the restoration project, the Webbs took painstaking care to preserve the historic look of the building.

While bringing the interior up to modern standards of luxury, the Webbs did everything possible to salvage the buildings historic appeal, refinishing the old maple floors on the upper and lower levels. They even retained the original Hillside Hotel sign: a slab of green wood and white lettering prominently displayed on the inn’s facade.

Other improvements, although not original to the hotel design, accent the structural attributes of the building, playing on such amenities as the waterfront view. New additions include an expanded kitchen area and a 100-foot-long second-story deck that over looks the bay.

More enhancements are yet to come as time and funding permit. Future projects include the conversion of two backyard barns into a fitness center, Clare said.

For the time being, the Webbs will simply focus on introducing the new Hillside Inn to prospective patrons and village residents. To that end, they plan to hold a housewarming party for the entire community during the early part of September.

“We hope to have some kind party for the community,” Clare said. “There’s so many people we’d like to thank for helping us.”

1-866-673-8456